**Shutterstock, Featureflash Photo Agency**
For many adults, the early 2010s are synonymous with the boyband era. Between 2012 and 2015, the music scene was dominated by boybands like One Direction and BTS, capturing the hearts of teens and their dedicated fans. This period is fondly remembered for its chart-topping albums, energetic concerts, and a plethora of merchandise.
During these years, One Direction emerged as the global leaders in the boyband scene, with their presence visible on virtually every type of media and product. However, since their split, no boyband has managed to achieve similar success, leaving a noticeable void for today’s generation of fans. Historically, boybands like The Beatles and NSYNC have defined their eras, but this is the first time since The Beatles that a boyband hasn’t dominated the global stage. The question now is whether there is still a demand for boybands or if fans have shifted their focus elsewhere. It seems that female solo artists, such as Taylor Swift with her monumental Eras Tour, have taken the spotlight, with rising stars like Olivia Rodrigo and Sabrina Carpenter following suit.
Simon Cowell, known for his role in launching popular acts, first gained fame in 2001 with *Pop Idol* but is best known for his work on *The X Factor* and *Got Talent*. Cowell has been instrumental in the careers of bands like One Direction, Little Mix, and Fifth Harmony. As the founder of Syco Entertainment, he has been a major force in the British music scene and beyond, earning numerous accolades for his contributions.
Despite his success, Cowell’s approach has not been without controversy. Many former band members have criticized his management style, citing issues like overwork and poor treatment. For example, Zayn Malik’s departure from One Direction in 2015 highlighted the intense pressure and mental strain the band endured, and similar issues were reported by Little Mix.
Cowell’s new project, *The Midas Touch*, is set to diverge from his previous talent shows by focusing on a documentary format rather than a reality competition. Despite the open call for young male singers, initial turnout has been underwhelming, possibly due to skepticism about Cowell’s past practices or the influence of the new social media landscape.
In the age of TikTok, which has transformed how music trends emerge and how artists gain fame, traditional talent shows may no longer hold the same appeal. TikTok has propelled artists like Doja Cat and Lil Nas X to stardom with viral hits, and has even revived interest in older tracks. This shift suggests that artists can now achieve fame through social media without the need for traditional platforms.
Cowell’s *The Midas Touch* may struggle to compete in this new environment where instant online success often outweighs traditional media exposure. The effectiveness of reality shows and documentaries in discovering new talent is increasingly questioned, as social media platforms provide more direct routes to fame.
If Cowell hopes to recreate the success of One Direction, he will need to address the concerns about his management practices and offer genuine support to his new band. Without a strong support system, any new boyband could face the same pitfalls that plagued his previous groups. The success of this endeavor will largely depend on whether it can adapt to the changing landscape of the music industry and provide a positive, supportive environment for its members.
